Never Simple: A Daughter’s True Story of a Mother’s Made-Up Life - book cover
Community & Culture
  • Publisher : Holt Paperbacks
  • Published : 11 Apr 2023
  • Pages : 288
  • ISBN-10 : 1250871115
  • ISBN-13 : 9781250871114
  • Language : English

Never Simple: A Daughter’s True Story of a Mother’s Made-Up Life

This gripping and darkly funny memoir "is a testament to the undeniable, indestructible love between a mother and a daughter" (Isaac Mizrahi).

Liz Scheier's mother was a news junkie, a hilarious storyteller, a fast-talking charmer you couldn't look away from, a single mother whose devotion crossed the line into obsession, and―when in the grips of the mental illness that plagued her―a masterful liar. On an otherwise uneventful afternoon when Scheier was eighteen, her mother sauntered into the room and dropped two bombshells. First, that she had been married for most of the previous two decades to a man Liz had never heard of and, second, that the man she had claimed was Liz's dead father was entirely fictional. She'd made him up―his name, the stories, everything.

Those big lies were the start, but not the end; it had taken dozens of smaller lies to support them, and by the time she was done she had built a fairy-tale, half-true life for the two of them. Judith Scheier's charm was more than matched by her eccentricity, and Liz had always known there was something wrong in their home. After all, other mothers didn't raise a child single-handedly with no visible source of income, or hide their children behind fake Social Security numbers, or host giant parties in a one-bedroom Manhattan apartment only to throw raging tantrums when the door closed behind the guests.

Now, decades later, armed with clues to her father's identity―and as her mother's worsening dementia reveals truths she never intended to share―Liz attempts to uncover the real answers to the mysteries underpinning her childhood. Trying to construct a "normal" life out of decidedly abnormal roots, she navigates her own circuitous path to adulthood: a bizarre breakup, an unexpected romance, and the birth of her son and daughter. Along the way, Liz wrestles with questions of what we owe our parents even when they fail us, and of how to share her mother's hilarity, limitless love, and creativity with children―without passing down the trauma of her mental illness. Never Simple is the story of enduring the legacy of a hard-to-love parent with compassion, humor, and, ultimately, self-preservation.

Editorial Reviews

March 2022 Indie Next Pick
The New York Times Book Review's "11 New Books We Recommend This Week," 3/10/22
People's Picks in People Magazine
Publishers Weekly "Books of the Week" Pick, 2/28/22
Featured on B&N Reads, "Top 10 Favorite eBooks This Year (So Far)"

"This powerful, conversational and ― above all ― honest memoir shakes hard truths out of the family tree."
―The New York Times Book Review

"‘You can still love someone who has caused you a lot of harm,' Scheier writes. Never Simple helped me understand the truth behind this statement ― and the guts it takes to say it… Scheier approaches her childhood like a detective…as she points out the cracks between the fiction she was raised with and the facts she pieced together on her own…By the time I reached the end, I was grateful that Scheier had weathered the storm."
―The New York Times, Group Text column

"Never Simple shows a child and young adult who, while living in chaos, has a maturity and wisdom that most adults don't possess. As a result, our response is more profound awe than merely a sympathetic aww… Some [readers] will see themselves while others will empathize. But in the end, Never Simple reminds every reader that no matter who we are and where we come from, life is never simple."
―USA Today

"An incredible book. I highly recommend Never Simple. It's hilarious, poignant, witty, and brutally honest. I loved it to pieces."
―Mira Bartók, author of The Memory Palace

"Scheier…debuts with a stunning and generous account of living with her mother's mental illness…Readers will find it hard to part with this one."
―Publishers Weekly, *starred*

"[A] jaw-dropping story…that will spark necessary conversation about transparency, mental health, abuse, addiction, housing, parenthood, egg donation, elder care, ...

Readers Top Reviews

DANA ISAACSON C
You've got to wonder how some people survive adversity and trauma and emerge as sensitive, smart, contributing members of society. If you read Liz Scheier's book, you might attribute it to wit and smarts, which she's got plenty of, but where did they come from? Are they genetic? That's just one question in the beautiful, dramatic, and engrossing tale that Liz Scheier survived to tell. It's got to be an electrifying shock when you realize that everything you think about yourself is a lie told to you by your mother. The circumstances of Liz Scheier's life are notably unusual--flabbergasting, traumatizing, sometimes really funny--but this elegant recounting of her ambitions, struggles, and emotions make her experience feel surprisingly universal. She pulls the reader in close while providing razor-sharp commentary on everything from mental illness, juvenile deliquency, ethical quandaries and --oh yeah -- true love. A wonderful satisfying read, intimately told, as though to a friend.
Holy crap, that was a moving read! Could not put it down. Should be a pulitzer prize winner. Seriously well written.
Beth Bexon DANA
This is the kind of "how did she ever survive childhood" memoirs I love to devour. Particularly interesting is figuring out how her mother managed to support both of them while never working. But it doesn't go as deep into the crazy episodes or how she is damaged by it as it might--the book is well constructed but there were places I wished her editor had pushed for more. But I rarely give 5 star reviews and I did quite enjoy reading this.
MelanieBeth Bexon
I love to read memoirs, but when a writer describes events or dialog in a way that sounds implausible and made up it hurts my enjoyment of the book. A lot of what Ms. Scheier writes sounds improbable or like she's trying to ramp up the drama. She writes about a time when she donated her eggs and then woke up afterward to find a check (her payment) laying on her chest. What clinic is going to place a check for thousands of dollars on a sleeping patient's chest. It's a small thing but so obviously not true that it made me wonder about a lot of the other things she wrote.
JanG. - byrdgrlMe
It takes courage to survive an unstable, abusive parent and it takes courage to share the intimate details of both that childhood and the often chaotic jumble of emotions that life with such a parent bring even into adulthood. Courage is also what is needed to forgive that parent after their death and to choose to find what tiny good memories there might be. Kudos to the author for her courage, for her honesty in her writing. Excellent book!